When I was first writing books for Hodder (circa 2002), I began to pick up lots of rumours and stories from the publishing industry in general. These tended to centre on the types of books different publishers produced and the kinds of projects editors were looking for across various fields. Faber was known at the time for putting out high-quality fiction in relatively short runs, but with an emphasis on singular works with a distinct style or tone. It was also strongly rumoured that if you wanted to publish with Faber, you needed to produce something notable or extraordinary that stood out on the bookshelves as a very individually marketable or high-toned piece of fiction.
When I first laid eyes on ‘Do You See What I See?’ by Peter Swanson, I was taken in by the cover (outstanding), the format (hardback), and the Sunday Times Bestseller banner (though these days that seems to be daubed on pretty much every jacket). Now, this might say quite a lot about my own high expectations of the publisher, but - seriously - for Faber to publish a painfully thin 150-page book with large print in hardcover for a £10 price tag (reduced to £5 at Asda), it has to be something pretty special, right? Admittedly, I’m not usually one for cosy Christmas mysteries, but I’ve enjoyed a few over the past year (Murder at Mistletoe Manor springs immediately to mind), so I took the chance.
I think the problem is that Peter Swanson’s book genuinely does feel like it’s going to be something special until it isn’t. The atmosphere is there (sort of), and the characters are all present and reasonably correct. They’re not fleshed out particularly well, but this also feels like part of the plan, as the book is so brief that you can't help but feel you’re building/racing to something exceptionally odd/satisfying: again, with the expectations, but that clearly worked as a sales strategy because I bought it (though I probably wouldn’t have taken the chance with the RRP).
Unfortunately, the book’s disappointing revelation/conclusion really forces you to look back on the entire read as something genuinely odd and unsatisfying, entirely like the sort of movie where you think ‘I’ll stay until the end because it must be saying SOMETHING’ and then you leave the cinema thinking ‘WTAF did I just watch?’
Sadly, I didn’t enjoy ‘Do You See What I See?’ at all. Maybe I missed something, and you will like it? Just don’t pay £10 for the privilege, I implore you. Note: for balance, his last novel, The Christmas Guest (by all accounts), was considered to be superb.
Do You See What I See? by Peter Swanson is published by Faber in hardback, priced at £10.

